Our newest spirit, this whiskey is named in honor of a tradition that took place within our historical firehouse-turned-distillery, which dates back to the 1800s. In the old days, if the firemen weren’t good enough, they were voted out in a ceremony called “black balling.” This was essentially a mix of voting yes or no by the firemen via a secret ballot. Well, this Rare Pennsylvania Whiskey tastes so good that we had no choice but to vote it out of the firehouse for your enjoyment.

Our whiskey is made from a 75% corn and 25% rye fermented mash and is carefully distilled and aged for 2 years with American oak to provide a robust yet smooth whiskey. 

Tasting Notes: Oak, Nut, Smoke, Caramel

Available in limited supply. 

750ml / 50% ABV / 100 proof

Five Saints Old Fashioned No.1
2 oz Five Saints Rare PA Whiskey
0.5 oz vanilla 
2 dashes orange bitters
2 dashes chocolate bitters
Garnish with orange peel, (if you’re feeling daring, option to smoke the glass)